हिंदी Call90310 74624
Home›Guides›Sanitary
Bathroom guide · toilets

Orissa pan or western toilet: which one for your Bihar home, and can you have both?

The short answer
WESTERNwhere anyone with knee or hip pain, an elder, a pregnant woman or a patient will use the bathroom every day. This settles it, whatever the rest of the family prefers.
ORISSA PANfor a common bathroom used by guests, workers or tenants, a village house, or where water comes by bucket.
BOTHif the house has two bathrooms: pan in the common one, western in the bedroom one. Most families building in Muzaffarpur end up here.

The real difference is not the debate about health. It is who uses the toilet and when it is fitted: the pan goes into the floor before the tiles; the western bowl sits on the tiles after.

530×425
mm, CERA Calina panThe Orissa pan we stock (S3010101), per CERA's list.
1.5–2 L
Bucket pour for a panWhat pour-flush pans are made for. A western bowl needs more.
220 / 300
mm, wall to drainThe western bowl must match it. Measure before you buy.
Same drain, two ways of sitting on it
Side sections of an Orissa pan and a western toilet Top: an Orissa pan set into the floor, its rim level with the tiles, a P-trap below it and a 110 mm pipe to the drain, needing a sunken or filled floor about 250 to 450 mm deep. Bottom: a floor-mounted western toilet standing on the finished tiles, its S-trap outlet going straight down at 220 or 300 mm from the wall, with a cistern on the wall. ORISSA PAN · IN THE FLOOR Rim level with the tile foot-rests on top Cistern + flush pipe P-trap 110 mm pipe to drain 250–450 mm under the floor WESTERN WC · ON THE FLOOR Bowl stands on the finished tile fixed after tiling S-trap: outlet goes straight down Cistern (two-piece bowls) 110 mm pipe to drain 220 or 300 mm from the finished wall
Not to scale. Pan size: CERA (Calina 530 × 425 mm). The 250–450 mm depth under the floor is usual practice for a sunken toilet floor; your pan's carton gives its own height. 220/300 mm: CERA's Chanel 220 and Cinco 300 pages.
Choose in one minute

Tick what is true for this one bathroom

Decide bathroom by bathroom, not for the whole house. The answer changes as you tick.

For this bathroom

Either works. Go by habit.

Nobody here has a reason that settles it. If the family is used to squatting, the pan costs less to fit. If you want a footstool-and-seat setup, a western bowl gives both.

    Ask for this set on WhatsApp
    Point by point

    The honest comparison for a Bihar household

    A tick marks the one that does better on that point. Count the ticks that matter for your family, not all of them.

    PointOrissa pan (Indian)Western toilet
    Knees, hips, old parentsNeeds a full squat and the strength to rise. The first thing to go after 60 or a knee problem.Sit and stand like a chair. A grab bar beside it makes it safer still: see toilet for old parents.
    Young, fit, used to squattingComfortable, quick, no seat to share.Fine, but some find sitting slower. A footstool fixes that (see health below).
    Small childrenSmall feet on the foot-rests over an open pan; most need holding.Needs a child seat ring or a stool, then easy.
    Touching the seatNothing to sit on, nothing to share.The seat is shared. Wipe it; cleaning matters more.
    Cleaning with a bucket and brushOpen shape, floor-level rim: a mug of water and a brush reach everything.Under the rim and behind the bowl need bending. Rimless models (Chanel 220, Cinco 300) are easier.
    Water with a bucketFlushes with a small pour. Pour-flush pans are made for 1.5–2 L.Needs a larger, quick pour to clear the bowl. Workable in a power cut, wasteful as the daily way.
    Water with a cisternThe same: a pan and a two-piece bowl can hang the same Covan cistern. Read the litres on the carton. BIS standard IS 774 cisterns are 6 or 10 L single flush, or 6/3 L dual.
    Guests and tenantsVillage and older guests prefer it; some town guests can't use it.Town guests expect it. Older village guests may stand on the rim: a reason to keep a pan in the common bathroom.
    Floor spaceThe rim is level with the floor, so the room stays walkable and a 3 × 4 ft toilet works.The bowl sticks out about 660 mm (Chanel 220) and needs knee room in front, about 600 mm as usual practice.
    When it is fittedAt the floor stage, before tiles. Decide early; changing later means breaking the floor.After tiles. The drain point is fixed early, the bowl itself can be chosen late.
    RepairsNothing moving except the cistern. A cracked pan needs the floor opened.Seat hinges and the cistern wear. A two-piece bowl lets you change one part at a time.
    Parts to buyPan, P-trap, cistern, flush pipe, bed of sand and cement.Bowl (seat cover comes with it), cistern or one-piece unit, connection pipe, angle valve, fixing set.

    Swipe the table sideways on a phone. Today's price for each part is on sanitary rates; the full parts list is below.

    The health argument, checked

    "Squatting is healthier": what the studies actually say

    Most pages on this question repeat it with no source. Here is what was measured, and what was not.

    What was found

    In Sikirov's study of 28 volunteers, a bowel movement took about 51 seconds squatting against 114 and 130 seconds on two seat heights, and people rated squatting as easier. A small Japanese X-ray study of 6 people found the passage straightened more when squatting.

    What was not proven

    Gastroenterologist Vincent Ho, reviewing these studies, writes there is no firm evidence that squatting prevents or cures piles. Squatting also raises blood pressure a little. The studies are small and short.

    The middle way

    The squatting in Sikirov's study was done on a low seat with the feet raised. A low footstool in front of a western bowl gives most of that posture, with a seat to hold the weight.

    For a parent with weak knees, sitting is safer whatever the posture studies say. A fall in a wet bathroom costs more than any of this.
    How each is fitted

    The pan is decided at the floor stage. The western bowl is decided at the drain stage.

    This is the part that catches families out: the choice has to be made weeks before anyone shops for the toilet itself.

    PANOrissa pan, step by step

    1. Leave depth under the toilet floor for the pan and its trap. On an upper floor that means a sunken slab, usually 250–450 mm deep; on the ground floor the earth filling gives it.
    2. Lay the 110 mm drain pipe to a fall towards the outlet, and set the P-trap at the pan's outlet point.
    3. Bed the pan in sand and cement, level both ways, with the rim at the finished tile height (not at the bare floor).
    4. Join the pan to the trap, fix the cistern on the wall and run the flush pipe.
    5. Fill the pan with water and check every joint before the tiles go down. The whole toilet floor needs waterproofing under the tiles.
    6. Tile around the pan last.

    Ask the mason where the rim will end up before he beds the pan. A rim left below the tile collects water; one left above it trips people.

    WESTERNFloor-mounted western, step by step

    1. Fix the drain point when the plumbing goes in: the middle of the pipe at 220 mm or 300 mm from the finished wall for an S-trap bowl. Write the figure on the wall.
    2. Cap the pipe and lay the floor and tiles. No sunken depth is needed for the bowl itself.
    3. Buy the bowl that matches the distance: Chanel 220 or Cinco 300 one-piece, or a two-piece Celeb or the CERA Conventional S-trap (S1053101) with a Covan cistern.
    4. Fix the bowl on the tiles with its connector and bolts, connect the cistern and the angle valve.

    Not sure which distance you have? 220 mm or 300 mm. Thinking of a wall-hung bowl? That needs a frame in the wall before plaster: wall-hung vs floor WC.

    Where each one joins the building work
    Construction stages and where the pan and the western bowl are fitted Six stages down the page: slab with sunken toilet floor, drain pipes, floor bed, floor tiles, wall tiles and fittings, final fixing. The Orissa pan is set at the floor bed stage, before tiles. The western bowl's drain point is fixed at the drain stage and the bowl itself is fitted at the end, after tiles. 1 Slab or plinthsunken toilet floor if a pan goes upstairs 2 Drain pipes laid110 mm line to the septic tank or nala 3 Floor bed and waterproofingwater test before tiles 4 Floor tilesanti-skid, sloped to the floor drain 5 Wall tiles, tapscistern brackets marked 6 Final fixingcistern, seat, basin PAN PIPE WC
    Black: the pan is set at stage 3. Red: the western drain point is fixed at stage 2 (dashed) and the bowl goes on at stage 6. Order shown is usual site practice.
    Can you have both?

    Yes. One of each is the usual answer here.

    At our counter, pans go to ground-floor common bathrooms, rented rooms and village houses; western bowls go to bedroom bathrooms and to any house with parents at home. A family building a new house usually buys one of each.

    A typical two-bathroom house
    Plan of a house with one Orissa pan and one western toilet Ground-floor plan. At the back, a common toilet with an Orissa pan and a separate bathing room, both opening to the passage, nearest the septic tank. Inside the bedroom, an attached bathroom with a western toilet for the parents. Both drain into one 110 mm line. Bedroomparents Hall Attached bathWESTERN Kitchen ToiletORISSA PAN Bathingfloor drain 110 mm line to septic tank →
    Common toilet at the back, nearest the septic tank, with a separate bathing room: the two-door layout common in Bihar. The parents' bathroom gets the western bowl. Plan is a sketch, not to scale.

    Two bathrooms: one of each

    Pan in the common toilet, western in the bedroom bathroom. Both can share one 110 mm line to the septic tank. Guests, workers and tenants use the pan; parents use the western bowl at night without climbing stairs.

    One bathroom now, one later

    Fit the pan in today's bathroom if that is the habit, but in the room planned for the second bathroom lay the drain pipe now and cap it at 220 or 300 mm from the wall. The western bowl then goes in without breaking a floor.

    Only one bathroom, mixed family

    Fit the western bowl and keep a footstool beside it for those who prefer the squatting posture. The reverse (a pan for a parent who cannot squat) does not work.

    A pan already, a parent now struggling

    A folding commode chair over the pan is a stop-gap for weeks, not years. The proper change is to take the pan out: replacing an Indian pan with a western toilet shows what breaks and what it needs.

    Village house bathroom in one set (pan, trap, cistern, pipes): bathroom kit, gaon ka ghar. Room sizes and where the WC goes: bathroom size and layout.

    On our shelf for each route

    What you buy for a pan, and what for a western toilet

    All CERA bathroom ware, sold genuine with a GST bill. Anything not listed, such as a different pan size or a dual-flush cistern, we can order for you; ask on WhatsApp for the time it takes.

    Sizes and catalogue numbers are from CERA's own pages. Warranty and registration: CERA at our store. Prices for every item, with the date: sanitary rates. Delivery is charged separately; ask for the amount for your site (delivery).

    Questions people ask us

    Short answers

    Which is better, Indian toilet or western toilet?

    Neither for everyone. Choose by who uses that bathroom every day. If anyone has knee or hip pain, is over about 60, pregnant or recovering from an operation, fit a western toilet there. For a common bathroom used by guests, workers or tenants, or where water comes by bucket, an Orissa pan works well. A house with two bathrooms can have one of each.

    Is squatting better for health?

    Small studies found squatting made passing stool quicker and easier (Sikirov, 28 people). A gastroenterologist's review in The Conversation says there is no firm evidence that squatting prevents or cures piles. A footstool under the feet on a western toilet gives a similar posture.

    Which uses less water?

    With a cistern, both use what the cistern holds; a pan and a two-piece bowl can hang the same Covan. The difference is with a bucket: a pan flushes with a small pour (pour-flush pans are made for 1.5–2 litres), while a western bowl needs a larger, quick pour.

    Is the Orissa pan fitted before or after tiling?

    Before. The pan and its P-trap are set in the floor and the tiles are laid around it. A floor-mounted western bowl is fixed on top of the finished tiles, after tiling. See Orissa pan for the fitting order.

    Can I change an Indian toilet to a western one later?

    Yes, but the pan has to be broken out, the hollow filled and levelled, and the drain brought to the right point for the bowl, then the floor retiled. Read replace Indian with western. Cheaper: leave a capped drain point for a western bowl now.

    Can a western toilet go upstairs without a sunken slab?

    Yes. A floor-mounted S-trap bowl needs only a drain pipe through the slab at 220 or 300 mm from the wall. A pan upstairs needs depth for its trap, which usually means a sunken slab planned when the roof is cast.

    What is the size of the CERA Calina Orissa pan?

    CERA lists the Calina S3010101 at 530 × 425 mm. There is also a bigger Calina, S3010102, at 580 × 440 mm. Check the catalogue number on the carton.

    Is there a toilet that works both ways?

    Anglo-Indian pans, which can be squatted on or sat on, are made by several brands. We can order one for you; ask on WhatsApp for the time it takes. Most families find one pan plus one western bowl more comfortable than a single compromise.

    Arun Tiwari
    Thekedar · site work, costs and plumbing, Tashya Ventures

    Arun Tiwari has fitted bathrooms on Muzaffarpur sites, from village pans to attached western bathrooms, and sells the CERA range at our Reva Road store. Pan sizes and catalogue numbers were checked on CERA's site on 13 Nov 2026; the health figures are from the studies named below. Where no maker or study gives a figure, the page says "usual practice".

    Where the facts come from

    1. CERA, squatting pans: Calina Orissa pan S3010101, 530 × 425 mm; Calina S3010102, 580 × 440 mm.
    2. CERA, polymer cisterns: Covan B1010110, single flush (capacity not published; read the carton).
    3. CERA, Chanel 220 and Cinco 300 product pages: concealed S-trap at 220 mm and 300 mm from the wall, 660 mm bowl length.
    4. Bureau of Indian Standards, IS 774:2004 flushing cisterns with Amendment 1: 6 and 10 L cisterns, 6/3 L dual flush added.
    5. SSWM, twin pits for pour flush: flush with 1.5 to 2 L (citing Roy et al. 1984).
    6. V. Ho, What's the best way to go to the toilet: squatting or sitting?, The Conversation, 16 Aug 2016: Sikirov's 28-volunteer study (51 s vs 114 and 130 s), the 6-person Japanese study, no firm evidence on piles, small rise in blood pressure, footstool advice.

    Tell us who will use each bathroom

    We'll suggest pan or western for each and send the full set with today's price on WhatsApp.

    TASHYABUILDING SOLUTIONS · MUZAFFARPUR
    WhatsApp 90310 74624tashyaventures.com